National School Lunch Program Still Important Part of Safety Net
LESTINA DONGO AND LINDSAY MONTE
APRIL 04, 2022 Recent data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP) shows that in 2019, prior to the pandemic, roughly 33.2 million children received school meals, including about 21.3 million who received free school lunches.
However, when the COVID-19 pandemic hit the United States a year later, it disrupted many facets of life, including closing schools for many and jeopardizing access to school meals.
As new policies were enacted in response to COVID-19, such as expanded eligibility for school lunch programs, food insecurity in households with children declined.
According to the Census Bureau’s experimental Household Pulse Survey (HPS), roughly 20% of at-risk households with children reported being food insecure — defined as sometimes or often not having enough to eat — in the early weeks of the pandemic, when many schools were closed.
But as new policies were enacted in response to COVID-19, such as expanded eligibility for school lunch programs, food insecurity in households with children declined.
New School Meal Policies During COVID
There were many policy changes designed to compensate for the loss of school meals due to pandemic-related school closures. Among them:
Many school districts offered meals that could be picked up or delivered via school bus transportation during this period.
The Pandemic Electronic Benefit Transfer program (P-EBT) provided emergency funds for nutritional benefits that were directly loaded on EBT cards for households with children that would normally receive free or reduced cost lunch if their schools were not partially or fully closed.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) waived the eligibility requirements for free lunch to allow school meal programs to provide safe, free healthy meals to all children and these flexibilities were extended through June of this year.
As these policies were implemented throughout the pandemic, food insecurity in households with children declined.
The decline is likely due in part to improving economic circumstances over the course of the pandemic (as well as the Child Tax Credit and stimulus payments). But our research shows that the change in food security still holds true when we control for economic variables.
Among households with children facing economic insecurity — defined here as those in which an adult indicated concern about their ability to pay the next month’s rent or mortgage — food insecurity fell by about 7 percentage points between the start of the pandemic (21.3% in April/May of 2020) and summer 2021 (14.2% in July/August 2021) when the most recent USDA policy changes were implemented.
Between summer 2021 and the back-to-school period in the fall, food insecurity levels among these at-risk households were not significantly different.
Free Meals for All Changed Who Receives Meals
When most kids returned to school last fall, school meal receipt looked more like it did pre-pandemic. HPS data collected December 1-13, 2021, show that 18.3 million school-enrolled children were reported to be receiving free meals at school.
However, expanded eligibility and availability changed who received school meals in the fall of 2021, which included some higher income households.
For example, roughly 58% of HPS households that received free school meals owned their homes in December, 2021, compared to 47% of SIPP householders in homes receiving free or reduced-price meals in 2019.
School Meals Still Part of Safety Net
These same HPS data show that although more households had access to free school meals during the pandemic, receipt was still higher in households that demonstrated financial need.
For example, roughly 39% of all households with children in school reported their child was receiving free school meals in December. However, 54% of households with kids that received funds from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program or SNAP, a means-tested food assistance program, reported receiving school meals.
Roughly half of adults in households with kids that reported difficulty meeting expenses reported receiving free school meals. The same was true of households with kids in which adults reported borrowing from friends and family to make ends meet.
Note that the estimates for SNAP households and households that borrowed to make ends meet was not significantly different.
Households With School-Enrolled Kids Receiving Free School Meals
Families Benefit From Program Expansions
HPS data also show the extent to which families continued to rely on pandemic-related expanded national school meals programs. In December 2021:
Roughly 15 million children ate meals on-site, at school or other locations.
Over 5 million children picked up meals at school or other locations.
Roughly 12 million school-enrolled children ages 5-18 received assistance through the expanded SNAP/P-EBT program.